‘Sirena Tuna’ available in Australia has been covered by the OU in America for the past few years. However, in shocking news ‘OU’ has decided to withdraw their hecsher. When approached Rabbi Eli Gutenburg of the ‘OU’ kashrut division stated that any good standing kashrut authority would not cover such tuna simply because of the non-tznius image on the top of the tuna.
The spokesman for Sirena tuna, David Huxley responded, “that the image is stepped in tradition and mysticism. We do not question your Jewish customs and nitpicking behavior into our cooking and packaging process so not question our image and secondly halachikly all that is considered erva is covered.” This last remark took the Jewish world by surprise due to the fact that Mr Huxley is an atheist, subsequently the assumption being that he did not understand religion let alone halacha.
The chief rabbi of ‘Kosher Australia,’ Rabbi Yaakov Weissgarden has deemed ‘Sirena Tuna’ not to be kosher because of the misleading packaging. Rabbi Weissgarden claimed that simple Jews might think that the tuna, which they are eating, comes from a mermaid that has never, throughout history, been kosher. This, in Rabbi Weissgarden’s opinion would cause the majority of Jews who do not have expert knowledge of kashrut to buy mermaid meat that is unquestionably trief.
Rabbi Weissgarden has also pointed to the Trade Practices Act 1978 section 52, misleading and deceptive conduct. Many have disregarded this argument as another rabbi touching on subject matter out of area of expertise in an attempt to prove his point.





